When should women start getting mammograms, and how often should they have them? These are important questions because finding breast cancer early can make treatment more successful. Research published in JAMA suggests that starting regular breast cancer screening at age 40, rather than waiting until 50, could help prevent more deaths. The findings also show why choosing the right screening schedule matters.

What Is Breast Cancer Screening?

Breast cancer screening means checking for signs of cancer before symptoms appear. The most common screening test is a mammogram, which uses low-dose X-rays to create images of breast tissue.

Mammograms can find changes in the breast that may be too small to feel. Detecting cancer earlier can make it easier to treat and improve the chances of survival.

There are two main types of mammograms:

  • Digital mammography: Takes X-ray images of the breast to look for possible cancer.
  • 3D mammography: Also called digital breast tomosynthesis, this takes multiple images from different angles to create a more detailed view of breast tissue.

Both methods are used to detect breast cancer, but researchers continue to study which screening schedules provide the greatest benefits.

What Did the Research Examine?

Researchers used six computer models to compare 36 different breast cancer screening strategies.

These models were based on real-world information about breast cancer rates, screening tests, treatments, and survival.

The researchers compared:

  • Starting mammograms at ages 40, 45, or 50.
  • Stopping screening at ages 74 or 79.
  • Getting mammograms every year or every two years.
  • Using standard digital mammography or 3D mammography.

The goal was to estimate how many breast cancer deaths each approach could prevent while also considering possible downsides.

Why Starting at Age 40 May Save More Lives

One of the most important findings was that starting mammograms at age 40 could prevent more breast cancer deaths than waiting until age 50.

For every 1,000 women who received 3D mammograms every two years, the models estimated:

  • Starting at age 40: About 8.2 breast cancer deaths prevented.
  • Starting at age 45: About 7.5 deaths prevented.
  • Starting at age 50: About 6.7 deaths prevented.

These estimates compared each screening schedule with having no mammograms.

Screening every two years from ages 40 through 74 was estimated to reduce breast cancer deaths by approximately 30%.

Importantly, these were computer predictions based on existing evidence, not results from a new clinical trial.

Should Women Get Mammograms Every Year?

The study also compared yearly mammograms with screening every two years.

Yearly screening was estimated to prevent more breast cancer deaths. However, it also led to more false alarms and unnecessary follow-up tests.

A false-positive result happens when a mammogram suggests something might be cancer, but further testing shows that it is not.

These results can lead to:

  • Additional mammograms or imaging tests.
  • Breast biopsies that turn out to be normal.
  • Anxiety while waiting for results.
  • Extra medical appointments and costs.

Another concern is overdiagnosis, which happens when screening finds a cancer that would never have caused symptoms or harmed the patient during their lifetime.

The researchers found that screening every two years offered a favorable balance between preventing deaths and limiting these potential harms.

Why Some Women May Benefit From More Screening

Not everyone has the same risk of developing breast cancer.

The models suggested that women with a higher risk of breast cancer may benefit more from earlier or more frequent screening.

The researchers also examined outcomes among Black women, who face important differences in breast cancer diagnosis and survival.

They found that screening Black women every year between ages 40 and 49, followed by screening every two years afterward, could help reduce differences in breast cancer deaths while maintaining a reasonable balance between benefits and harms.

These findings highlight the importance of considering individual risk rather than using the same approach for everyone.

What Are the Current Screening Recommendations?

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends that women at average risk of breast cancer receive a mammogram every two years from ages 40 through 74.

However, some women may need a different schedule based on their personal risk.

Factors worth discussing with a healthcare provider include:

  • A family history of breast cancer.
  • Inherited genetic changes linked to breast cancer.
  • Dense breast tissue.
  • Previous breast conditions or treatments that increase cancer risk.

Women with a higher risk may need earlier screening, more frequent testing, or additional imaging.

What This Means for You

Breast cancer screening can save lives, and this research supports the benefits of beginning regular mammograms at age 40.

However, the best screening schedule depends on your age, medical history, and personal risk factors.

If you are approaching 40 or have concerns about breast cancer, talk with your healthcare provider about when to begin screening and how often to return.

Regular mammograms, along with paying attention to new breast changes, can help detect cancer earlier, when treatment may be more effective.

Source

  1. Trentham-Dietz A, Chapman CH, Jayasekera J, et al. Collaborative modeling to compare different breast cancer screening strategies: a decision analysis for the US Preventive Services Task Force. JAMA. 2024;331(22):1947-1960. doi:10.1001/jama.2023.24766. Accessed by: https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2023.24766

You May Also Like